Carrier commission reconciliation for independent insurance agencies

How to reconcile carrier commission statements to bank deposits

October 03, 2026•6 min read

Short answer: reconcile each carrier statement to the deposit that paid it, line by line, every month. Book the statement total as commission revenue in the month the statement covers, clear the receivable when the deposit lands, and investigate every difference before you close the month.

Why the deposit is not your revenue

Most agencies record commission when the money hits the bank. That ties the P&L to carrier payment timing, not to the business you wrote. A carrier that pays late makes a strong month look weak, and a chargeback hides inside a net deposit where nobody sees it.

The monthly method

  1. Collect every statement. Download each carrier and MGA statement for the month, direct bill and agency bill, before you start. Keep a checklist of carriers so a missing statement is obvious.
  2. Book the statement, not the deposit. Post each statement total to commission revenue and to a commissions receivable account for that carrier, dated in the month the statement covers.
  3. Match the deposit. When the carrier pays, apply the deposit against that carrier's receivable. A clean match clears the balance to zero.
  4. Work the differences. A balance left in the receivable is a short pay, a fee netted out, a chargeback on a cancelled policy, or a deposit you applied to the wrong carrier. Name each one.
  5. Compare to your management system. Tie the statement detail back to the policies in your agency management system. A policy you wrote that is missing from the statement is money you are owed.
  6. Review the aging. Any carrier receivable older than one statement cycle gets a call or an email to the carrier.

What usually goes wrong

  • Several carriers pay in one sweep deposit, so nobody can say which carrier paid what.
  • Chargebacks are netted against new commission and never show as their own line.
  • Contingent and bonus commissions land once a year and inflate one month.
  • Producer splits are paid from the deposit before the statement is checked.

What you get when it is done right

You can answer three questions on the 12th of every month: what each carrier owes you, what you earned last month, and what you owe each producer. That is the base for every other number in the agency.

Want a second set of eyes on your file? Consultgenix runs the books for independent P&C agencies in Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach. Book a free 30 minute file review at consultgenix.com. You leave with a written scope and a fixed monthly price.

blog author avatar

Derrek Space

Finance executive with twenty years in FP&A, finance transformation and insurance finance, including head of finance for AIG's consumer insurance business across 17 Latin American markets.

LinkedIn logo icon
Back to Blog